Native News

Heinrich Took Tribal, Energy Money while Negotiating a Bill that Threatens Sovereignty, Lands  


Sen. Martin Heinrich is cosponsoring the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA) as a way to lower energy costs and speed infrastructure projects. But critics—including tribal leaders, national organizations and a group of 17 state attorneys general—say its historic-preservation provisions could weaken sovereignty and burden the very offices responsible for consultation. 

In a Nov. 17 press release, Heinrich said he had worked to incorporate feedback from Tribes and New Mexicans. He argued that the bill would improve consultation by requiring federal agencies to consult at multiple stages of the historic-preservation process. He also said faster permitting and grid connections could help lower electricity bills.

But tribal organizations say that his remarks amount to gaslighting and equivocation on his position regarding Title III, a provision that would cause a severe erosion of Tribal sovereignty and protections for their lands.  

“Once again, Senator Martin Heinrich and Senator Sheldon Whitehouse are lying to Indian Country. Right now, the law ALREADY requires agencies to consult with Tribal Nations on all projects that affect Tribal lands, as well as ceded, ancestral, and aboriginal lands,” the National Association of Tribal Historic Preservation Officers said in a statement. “BAAJA would so severely restrict the types of projects, as well as the harms those projects might cause, on which Agencies must consult with Tribes, that it effectively eliminates consultation for most federal projects. Senator Heinrich is so desperate to sell BAAJA, he continues to play snake oil salesman, when he could have avoided this altogether if he had consulted with Tribes and listened to them in the first place. 

Related by Suzette Brewer: Fast-Tracked BAAJA Puts Tribal Sovereignty, Lands at Risk

“Every single point he made [in the release] isn’t just bending the truth,” concurred a tribal policy analyst who requested anonymity to discuss the legislation. “It’s a flat-out lie.” 

Campaign finance records, however, suggest Heinrich was soliciting both sides, accepting contributions from both energy interests and tribal governments as he continued working in secret to undermine Tribal sovereignty.

His filings list $120,500 in itemized contributions to Heinrich for Senate campaign through Sept. 30 from PACs and committees associated with energy, utilities, and renewable energy. This figure comes from reviewing organizations identified by name; it includes a $5,000 contribution from the Pattern Energy Group Inc. PAC as a PAC contribution. 

A review of FEC filings also identified $80,400 in tribal contributions to Heinrich’s Senate campaign from Jan. 1, 2023, through Sept. 30, 2026, from 17 tribal entities from 11 states. That total includes $10,800 in 2025–26 contributions from the Chickasaw Nation, the Miccosukee Tribe and the Saginaw Chippewa Indian Tribe. 

Separately, the Heinrich Victory Fund reported $28,000 from seven tribal entities through Oct. 14, 2026. Together, the records show $108,400 in identified tribal contributions across the periods reviewed; the Victory Fund is a joint fundraising committee, and its receipts are not all retained by Heinrich’s campaign. 

States’ Objections to BAAJA Gaining Steam

Objections to BAAJA’s provisions now extend beyond tribal organizations, drawing strong pushback from states as well. In a Nov. 9th letter to Senate leaders from 17 state attorneys general said the revised bill contains unfunded mandates that would add requirements and shorten deadlines for state and tribal historic-preservation programs while eliminating guaranteed funding. 

Additionally, they argued that underfunded, understaffed offices could struggle to meet the new requirements, risking suspension of their funding and, in some cases, federal takeover of state programs. The attorneys general warned that the result could be more delay, not less.

The letter also said that the amendment to Section 106 restored mandatory consultation but left federal agencies broad discretion over key decisions, including whether adverse effects to historic resources could be outweighed by other considerations, which complicate Heinrich’s claim that the amendment’s consultation provisions resolve the central concerns. 

“…[A]lthough we appreciate the constructive engagement over the past few weeks, we continue to have substantial concerns,” they wrote. “As detailed below, and among other defects, BAAJA would harm states’ and tribes’ abilities to protect water, historic, cultural, and natural resources under the Clean Water Act, the National Historic Preservation Act, the National Environmental Policy Act, and the Endangered Species Act, and would impinge on state and tribal sovereignty.”

In the meantime, Tribal opposition remains unequivocal. NCAI has called for Title III to be withdrawn, saying its proposed changes to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act would undermine tribal sovereignty and strip protections for sacred sites. It says more than 70 Tribal Nations are represented among more than 215 entities whose letters, resolutions, statements and other materials oppose BAAJA and the proposed Section 106 changes. 

Heinrich’s political records show money from energy interests and tribal governments. The accountability question is whether BAAJA’s consultation process gives tribes meaningful influence—and whether its preservation offices will have the resources to do the work the bill requires.

Tribal contributions to Heinrich’s committees should not be read as an endorsement of BAAJA or as a proxy for the views of other Nations. 

The post Heinrich Took Tribal, Energy Money while Negotiating a Bill that Threatens Sovereignty, Lands   appeared first on Native News Online.



Source link

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Most Popular

To Top